skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Hit or miss on this one, but mostly miss. The pizza could be better and sometimes varies based on who is making it. Most of the apps are frozen and might be equivalent to what you would get in a large bag at BJ's or Costco (lots of breading, and breading on top of breading). Some specialty pizzas are O.K. and the sandwiches can be ... read more
Eastender824 via google.com - Nov 30, 2020
We had a wonderful experience at this place. We loved the great atmosphere and the menu. The staff members were very attentive. I’m glad we eventually decided to try this place.
Tknhjnc Robinson via google.com - Nov 20, 2020
I delivered an uber order of a grandma pie and the herbal scent that filled the car was mouthwatering. I was so bothered that I couldn't eat the pie myself I went back to the pizzeria and got some for myself. I don't even eat tomatoes but I enjoyed every piece. It was a pleasant change from the cheesey cardboard I'm used to from half ... read more
Jessica Brattole via google.com - Nov 15, 2020
I was delivering this beautiful Pizza that has the most delectable aroma in the process I decided to get some pizza myself after trying said Pizza I decided that all other pizzas are now null and void the same to the negative feedback to the creators of this delicious Pizza, if you have anything negative to say forget about it...
Kristopher Galante via google.com - Nov 15, 2020
Good service, good food, i enjoy checking out the variety of pies that they make.
brooke woods via google.com - Nov 13, 2020
Best Grandma slice on LI!! Soooo ...
Best Grandma slice on LI!! Soooo good! Their sauce is amazing! Bit of advice...call ahead, even for just a slice. They go through Grandma slices like crazy! All the food here is really good. It's a MUST if you're in the area!
Foodie F. via yelp.com - Oct 22, 2020
Good service ... read more
Robert Caccavalla via google.com - Oct 20, 2020
The House special pizza is a must try!
Adithya L R via google.com - Oct 20, 2020
Excellent chicken caesar salad wraps in whole wheat wrap. Yum! And excellent pizza.
Ann Safire via google.com - Oct 19, 2020
So much food for what you pay!
Ava Dawydiak via google.com - Oct 8, 2020
Good pizza but pricey ... read more
Rebecca Dellavilla via google.com - Oct 5, 2020
Ordered takeout, all was ready ...
Ordered takeout, all was ready on time on one of their busiest nights. We had the grandma's and the Thai chicken pizza, both were excellent, we also ordered the greek salad, that was good as well.
Louis R. via yelp.com - Oct 4, 2020
Totally recommend this place! The ...
Totally recommend this place! The pizza was great and pasta was absolutely amazing! The marinara sauce was very delicious..
Padideh N. via yelp.com - Oct 4, 2020
Not cheap, but very lovely, especially at dusk.
Eric Justin Johnson via google.com - Sep 29, 2020
Fabulous food and great service! ...
Fabulous food and great service!  Best Italian in area. Recommend pasta Bologna's and pasta fagioli.
Andrea S. via yelp.com - Sep 25, 2020
Their Buffalo Bites are awesome and their pizza always hits the spot. They go great with Westhampton Brewery beer. 👍👍 ... read more
Kyle Kim via google.com - Sep 13, 2020
The food is spectacular but I cant see how it is 42.50 for 4 slices of pizza and a cheese calzone ... read more
Donald Bennett via google.com - Sep 11, 2020
Ordered takeout. Everything delicious ...
Ordered takeout. Everything delicious, as usual. Small Gorgonzola salad has plenty of greens, cranberries, walnuts and Gorgonzola for at least two and the dressing is delicious! Entrees and pasta dishes are good portions...definitely going to enjoy leftovers.  
Prices have gone up and they now charge an extra fee for "non cash" pa ... read more
R G. via yelp.com - Aug 11, 2020
Their salad dressing is so so good ...
Their salad dressing is so so good. I wish they told you the ingredients it's kind of annoying not know what you are eating. Pizza is amazing, slightly overpriced, but that's the hamptons. Get the buffalo chicken pizza if ur feeling like hungry ... read more
Julia F. via yelp.com - Aug 6, 2020
So happy they have gluten free ...
So happy they have gluten free pies. I have orders regular pies for many years and were always delish. But, for those who have dietary restrictions, their gluten free pies are the best around!
Heather B. via yelp.com - Jul 29, 2020
Great food ... read more
Donna Glasgow via google.com - Jul 22, 2020
(Translated by Google) Nice place (Original) Bonito lugar ... read more
María Matute via google.com - Jul 18, 2020
We take out from here quite a lot ...
We take out from here quite a lot. I've been very impressed with everything that we've had and the garlic knots are the best I've had anywhere.
I recommend the Caesar salad. Ask them to ease up on the croutons but the dressing is excellent.
Great pasta and really good tomato sauce.
Sausage and pepper here is one of the be ... read more
Joel L. via yelp.com - Jul 16, 2020
A fantastic pizzeria that I was ...
A fantastic pizzeria that I was lucky enough to grow up around. They have excellent pizza and amazing specialty slices. It's in an okay accessible location but has good seating with the choice of indoors and outdoors. Their Sicilian pizza is the best pizza I've ever had!!!!
Gustave L. via yelp.com - Jul 11, 2020
Good place with outdoor seating. Reasonable prices and friendly staff.
Kaushik Londhe via google.com - Jul 7, 2020
food is very good. some of the ...
food is very good. some of the staff are just not happy people.  food is consistent do not ise their online delivery or online pickup the services they  use can ruin your dinner and not do the right thing.  the restaurant blames them also ... read more
Leo U. via yelp.com - Jul 6, 2020
Great pizza high prices ... read more
Michael Reilly via google.com - Jul 3, 2020
Went with my grandchildren the pizza was great. Will definitely go back when visiting West Hampton Beach.
maureen adamo via google.com - Jul 1, 2020
Very Very Good pizza and pastas. Fast delivery and again very good food!
Wine Guy via google.com - Jun 30, 2020
Wonderful v busy, Tasty ... read more
Raju Appukuttan via google.com - Jun 27, 2020
Family owned pizzeria. Great pizza. Nice thin crust. Dinners are awesome too.
jennifer c via google.com - Jun 21, 2020
Best pizza in Westhampton. The ...
Best pizza in Westhampton. The care center orders there frequently and we are never disappointed. Very personable and food is great.
Emily D. via yelp.com - Jun 17, 2020
Great Pizza ... read more
BECKY C LONG via google.com - Jun 14, 2020
Best pizza in town!  I would love ...
Best pizza in town!  I would love to know their sauce recipe!  Also has nice seating area outside.  The workers are all friendly and busy.  They have variety of italian foods.
Susan C. via yelp.com - Jun 11, 2020
This site is my favorite restaurant. Of all restaurants I know I love it most. I always suggests to my friends to go to that place. when I I need a superb dinner, this is the place that comes straight to my mind. Great and all kinds of food and a large menu.trained staff, and great atmosphere. In addition to that, the tariff is m ... read more
Brooks Santiago via google.com - May 21, 2020
Great experience AS ALWAYS!
L Brunskill via google.com - Mar 4, 2020
On the road again brings me to ...
On the road again brings me to yet another pizza stop in my travels.
Strip mall style store with a nice entrance and retro feel with the decor. Very clean.
Friends calling me the garlic knot gangster as you can usually gauge the shop by the quality of its knots...lol
Ordering 6 and sauce to stay has the usual wait and time t ... read more
Carolyn M. via yelp.com - Mar 1, 2020
Tasty pizza and the staff are very friendly and helpful.
Trevor Henry via google.com - Feb 23, 2020
Great pizza and soup ... read more
Omrit Naftali Filtser via google.com - Feb 22, 2020
I like this place! They serve decent food, their menu is decent, The chef in that place is well trained, I enjoy very much eating all their dishes. The food is consistently fresh and tasty, the service towards the clients is very good too. I visit often this restaurant and I was never discontended. I recommend it with no hesitation.
D Bolton via google.com - Feb 5, 2020
This happens to be one of my favorite ...
This happens to be one of my favorite pizzeria's !!! The portions are tremendous and fresh one of my favorites is there chicken Caesar salad which I happen to love their pizza is nice and crisp never soggy and they are mozzarella it's nice and fresh and not salty the sauce is very good I gave it four stars only because they don't put ... read more
Susan S. via yelp.com - Feb 5, 2020
Most of their pizza is pretty decent but their Hawaiian is pretty bad due to the lack of sauce and use of way too many giant chunks of pineapple.
John Kosequat via google.com - Feb 2, 2020
Great food and service excellent ... read more
Charles Buczynski via google.com - Feb 1, 2020
Great place ! All is friendly to me! Love it.Regular on Monday and Tuesday!
Christopher Soundy via google.com - Jan 21, 2020
Love this place. Specialty pizzas are great ... read more
Natausha Magee via google.com - Jan 18, 2020
When it comes to choosing a pizza spot in the area, you really don't have many choices. However, that's fine as you don't need any other choices! The pizza is as good as it's going to get! great variety (depending on day and time you go in) ... read more
kristen siben via google.com - Jan 14, 2020
When it comes to choosing a pizza ...
When it comes to choosing a pizza spot in the area, you really don't have many choices. However, that's fine as you don't need any other choices! The pizza is as good as it's going to get! great variety (depending on day and time you go in)

The BBQ slice is probably my favorite ... read more
Kristen S. via yelp.com - Jan 14, 2020
Calamari sabroso...no es solo pizza...me encanta!!!!!!
Xiomara Rivera via google.com - Jan 13, 2020
Best pizza on the east end. Quick, reliable, and homey feeling at the restaurant.
Buddy Inacar via google.com - Jan 9, 2020
Go here often for lunch since we work near by. Never had a bad experience.
Aodhan Browning via google.com - Dec 28, 2019
Great place for good Italian food!
Colleen Zollo via google.com - Dec 26, 2019
Delicious food with great service ... read more
Orcun Unsal via google.com - Dec 14, 2019
Not number one but definitely good ... read more
Phisher DeRidder via google.com - Dec 5, 2019
Decent ... read more
Dan Swezey via google.com - Dec 1, 2019
Great service!
Robert Boyle via google.com - Nov 28, 2019
This is a great hometown authentic ...
This is a great hometown authentic Italian eatery, no matter what you have, you will want more.
Greg C. via yelp.com - Nov 25, 2019
Nice people, great service, good food.
J P via google.com - Nov 22, 2019
Amazing pizzas by the slice, great prices. Not quite as good as other pizza places but a great lunch stop ... read more
christopher walton via google.com - Nov 15, 2019
Freaking awesome ... read more
Ed Menchaca via google.com - Nov 13, 2019
I love this place! I used to order ...
I love this place! I used to order Philly Steak and Cheese with the works!
Then Tony recommended a Potato and Egg Hero with melted mozz,  I kept saying no, its okay....so he sent me a Free one anyway! The Bomb! Now I am on a diet so I get The Out East Salad with their homemade vegetable dressing!
The Best! Thanks guys!!!!
Alan S. via yelp.com - Nov 7, 2019
The pizza is excellent and that's ...
The pizza is excellent and that's what my review is based on.  However, I tried a chicken parmesan hero on my last visit and that's why it's only 3 stars.  

4 stars for the pizza, -1 star for the hero.  I don't think I have ever seen chicken pounded so thin!  A few of the pieces had more breading than chicken!  I'd say the pie ... read more
Bob B. via yelp.com - Nov 6, 2019
Tonino's is always good.Good pizza and Italian food.😛 ... read more
joseph cacciato via google.com - Nov 4, 2019
We ordered lunch the other day ...
We ordered lunch the other day from work....and I just have to tell you the Wild Mushroom pizza is something to race about. I can't rave enough about it. When the gals at work told me about it...I was skeptical. I ordered a "back up slice" of just cheese, just in case.

Boy did I regret that...I could have eaten two of those m ... read more
Cristie G. via yelp.com - Nov 2, 2019
My pizza was good, staff was nice!
Ruth Jean-Baptiste via google.com - Oct 21, 2019
Surprised Very good ... read more
Howard rothbein via google.com - Oct 20, 2019
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire