skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

I ordered delivery yesterday and the food was absolutely amazing. We had a whole bunch of apps including Mac and cheese bites, buffalo bites, fried ravioli and much more. Delivery was super fast and pleasant and the food was outstanding. Only negative would be that there weren’t any leftovers bc it was so yummy!
Tatiana Shulman via google.com - Jun 25, 2022
Omg custom spaghetti and meatball pie. Sorry I had to grab a slice before pic. Thank you toninos!!!!!
elizabeth beveridge via google.com - Jun 22, 2022
All the food is awesome. Pizza is sooooo goood.
Thomas Lucien via google.com - Jun 12, 2022
Pizzas are great, and very understanding for their clients ... read more
Samantha Deenik via google.com - Jun 6, 2022
Best bang for the buck ... read more
Michael Falzarano via google.com - May 22, 2022
Guy working the counter was great. He saw I had my daughter with me took out her slice early so it wasn't too hot and offered to cut it up into small bites. Overall the food was fantastic. Try the vodka slice!
Calvin Starke via google.com - May 17, 2022
It’s the best ... read more
Frank Carbone via google.com - Apr 13, 2022
I have to say it is really good pizza ,nice people , polite ,you can use the bathroom and there really good when you order and go pick it up ... read more
ANTHONYCAVALLO68 Cavallo via google.com - Apr 7, 2022
Big slice, tasty ... read more
Nick G via google.com - Mar 27, 2022
ABSOLUTELY AMAZING pizza. We just picked up 4 different slices from here and all of them were delicious. The regular slice had such a sweet sauce. The Sicilian slice also had a really great sauce and whatever dough they used made it light. Nothing like those heavy doughs we’ve been used to. The pepperoni slice was also amazing. ... read more
S P via google.com - Mar 14, 2022
Consistent and good ... read more
Jadne Snyder via google.com - Mar 2, 2022
Delicious, quick and amazing service!
K Roy via google.com - Feb 8, 2022
Great pizza, excellent service ... read more
Lana D via google.com - Feb 1, 2022
I was visiting a friend and stopped here for some dinner. The food was delicious and we didn't wait for ever like some places.
William Daily via google.com - Jan 30, 2022
Food is great. Place is always clean. 1 suggestion is they should be.a little more. Sociable with their clientele. I was standing waiting for my food to heat up in a very uncomfortable silence ... read more
Elizabeth Tyson via google.com - Dec 30, 2021
Pizza is pretty good. Entrees are very very mediocre. Expensive for the quality.
Theryn Gibbons via google.com - Nov 25, 2021
Excellent ... read more
Carolyn Levenson via google.com - Nov 12, 2021
Pizza was good could have been a little bit greasier. Chicken farm sandwich needed seasoning. Sausage and pepper sandwich was excellent. All in all would recommend a good place to get some good Italian ... read more
Andy Mcmillan via google.com - Nov 7, 2021
Best in Westhampton
Good pizza, great pasta, and great service. We have tried most all pizza places in Westhampton but we always come back here. Friendly staff and they get your order out fast.
maughanm via tripadvisor.ca - Oct 14, 2021
Very Friendly ... read more
Irene Anderson via google.com - Oct 13, 2021
Great pizza great entrees. Cold Italian heros great.
Barbara Considine via google.com - Oct 13, 2021
My favorite lunch spot while visiting west Hampton area.
Ronald Crutcher via google.com - Oct 7, 2021
Better than most pizza places out east.
Luke Rogers via google.com - Oct 6, 2021
Great food!! Great service!!
Renee Sevcik via google.com - Sep 23, 2021
The BEST Eggplant Parmesan. Hands down.
Cali Nicole Boutique via google.com - Sep 23, 2021
Italian food ... read more
Samuel Rafalin via google.com - Sep 10, 2021
Pizza is of high quality.
Kenneth Wurman via google.com - Aug 19, 2021
Great pizza that was really tasty.
tinribbs via google.com - Aug 17, 2021
excellent food very reasonably and large portions ... read more
Steve Rera via google.com - Aug 15, 2021
One of the best pizza places on Long Island at least the best of the Hamptons ... read more
keith aaron via google.com - Jul 25, 2021
Best prices Italian food from west Hampton. Fresh quality, delicious. Best delivery service in town!
Gaetano Logiudice via google.com - Jul 13, 2021
Pasta was made by a god.
Phillip Dhanpaul III via google.com - Jul 12, 2021
Never disappointed.... enjoy ... read more
Abraham Gottfried via google.com - Jul 9, 2021
What a perfect slice. Either I didn't know or I forgot that they cut their pies into six rather than eight, which is good because you get longer to savor the great sauce and a dough that is delicately balanced between chewy and fluffy with a slight crisp on the bottom. Delicious.
Joshua Huizing via google.com - Jun 2, 2021
Mussels are delicious ... read more
Jim Molinari via google.com - Jun 1, 2021
Always great ... read more
Joseph Corrigan via google.com - May 28, 2021
Toninos is one of my favorite pizzerias heading out east! Great establishment! Very clean, amazing Italian food. Staff is very friendly, and the family who runs this place are so warm and welcoming. Super busy at lunch but they're quick n efficient. I go on my lunch break often. Would definitely recommend.
Heather Robinson via google.com - May 11, 2021
Excellent Best I have had in years ... read more
William Distelhurst via google.com - May 5, 2021
The best pizza the best Italian food anywhere. friendly staff, clean restaurant what more can you ask for ... read more
Mark Ebert via google.com - Mar 31, 2021
Best pizza in west hamptons ... read more
Juan Murillo via google.com - Mar 27, 2021
This spot is one of my favorites! Good rates, large dishes and the staff members are always very welcoming.
David Carey via google.com - Mar 13, 2021
Luv the eggplant parm!!!
C P via google.com - Mar 2, 2021
Great pizza, huge portions, amazing prices? What's not to love here? Clean facilities, friendly staff, a great lunch experience. Definitely recommend it.
Dom via google.com - Feb 24, 2021
Awesome pizza, great service, cute girl works the front.. all these keep me coming back for more ... read more
Ioannis Sitaras (SupraMan7) via google.com - Feb 18, 2021
My favorite pizza place. Slices used to be huge, now regular sized but still very good, a lot of options and friendly staff .
Christionna C via google.com - Jan 6, 2021
BEST pizza place on the east end!! The quality is always on point, and never disappoints.
Tory Albert via google.com - Dec 29, 2020
Wow!! great pizza!! The pizza, calzones, salads, & desserts are top quality, always fresh. We really enjoyed our dinner from here. Good prices too.
amanda sunshine via google.com - Dec 21, 2020
If you like pizza hut or dominoes go some where else. If you are a real New Yorker this is Your place. Nice crispy crust not over cooked ,not burnt. Really good Pizza beats Francessas in Hampton Bays hands down. Staff is very friendly they want your business unlike other Hamptons spots who could care less you were there. Go for it.
chris wanser via google.com - Dec 5, 2020
Hit or miss on this one, but mostly miss. The pizza could be better and sometimes varies based on who is making it. Most of the apps are frozen and might be equivalent to what you would get in a large bag at BJ's or Costco (lots of breading, and breading on top of breading). Some specialty pizzas are O.K. and the sandwiches can be ... read more
Raymond Medina via google.com - Nov 30, 2020
We had a wonderful experience at this place. We loved the great atmosphere and the menu. The staff members were very attentive. I’m glad we eventually decided to try this place.
Tknhjnc Robinson via google.com - Nov 20, 2020
I delivered an uber order of a grandma pie and the herbal scent that filled the car was mouthwatering. I was so bothered that I couldn't eat the pie myself I went back to the pizzeria and got some for myself. I don't even eat tomatoes but I enjoyed every piece. It was a pleasant change from the cheesey cardboard I'm used to from half ... read more
Jessica Brattole via google.com - Nov 15, 2020
I was delivering this beautiful Pizza that has the most delectable aroma in the process I decided to get some pizza myself after trying said Pizza I decided that all other pizzas are now null and void the same to the negative feedback to the creators of this delicious Pizza, if you have anything negative to say forget about it...
Kristopher Galante via google.com - Nov 15, 2020
Good service, good food, i enjoy checking out the variety of pies that they make.
Brooke via google.com - Nov 13, 2020
Good service ... read more
Robert Caccavalla via google.com - Oct 20, 2020
The House special pizza is a must try!
Adithya L R via google.com - Oct 20, 2020
Excellent chicken caesar salad wraps in whole wheat wrap. Yum! And excellent pizza.
Ann Safire via google.com - Oct 19, 2020
Great Food And People!!
Alan Starr via google.com - Oct 17, 2020
So much food for what you pay!
Ava Dawydiak via google.com - Oct 8, 2020
Good pizza but pricey ... read more
Rebecca Dellavilla via google.com - Oct 5, 2020
Not cheap, but very lovely, especially at dusk.
Eric Justin Johnson via google.com - Sep 29, 2020
Their Buffalo Bites are awesome and their pizza always hits the spot. They go great with Westhampton Brewery beer. 👍👍 ... read more
Kyle Kim via google.com - Sep 13, 2020
The food is spectacular but I cant see how it is 42.50 for 4 slices of pizza and a cheese calzone ... read more
Donald Bennett via google.com - Sep 11, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire